BERLIN — At a defining moment for the European Union, its largest country, Germany, appeared divided and its leader absent, raising significant concerns about what kind of leadership Chancellor Angela Merkel can offer as the region tries to stabilize financial markets and shore up its common currency.
As Mrs. Merkel sat in Moscow on Sunday watching a military paradecommemorating Nazi Germany’s defeat in World War II, her governingcoalition lost control of Germany’s most populous state, and with itthe upper house of Parliament. And while European finance ministers andthe International Monetary Fundhammered out a nearly $1 trillion rescue fund to deal with the region’sdebt problems, the German finance minister, Wolfgang Schäuble, wasconfined to a hospital, unable to attend the meeting.
“What Now, Chancellor?” asked the front page of the tabloid Bild onMonday. It was the very same newspaper, Germany’s highest-circulationdaily, that led and gave voice to a populist campaign against bailingout Greece.
Heeding that public anger, Mrs. Merkel delayed concerted action tocombat the financial turmoil that moved beyond Greece and threatenedthe stability of the region that uses the euro as its currency.
“German politicians used this only for domestic political purposes,narrowly formulating the most traditional views of German voters,” saidJacques Mistral, director of economic studies at the French Institute of International Relations in Paris. “They missed this opportunity and gave a poor picture to the rest of the world of their leadership.”
The influential daily Süddeutsche Zeitung was among several that suggested that President Nicolas Sarkozyof France, who canceled his own trip to Moscow because of the eurocrisis, had claimed the spotlight from a dithering Mrs. Merkel. “Nowshe must live with the judgment that the rescue umbrella à la françaisecould have been put together weeks ago, but she drove the price higherunnecessarily,” the paper said Monday.
Her supporters, and even some detractors, say the picture is morecomplex. They say Mrs. Merkel is a politician skilled in the art of thepossible, who exercised patience to overcome difficult circumstances.
In this more sympathetic version, Mrs. Merkel helped raise the pressureon the Greek government to agree to tough but necessary cutbacks inpublic spending. At the same time, the resentment of average Germansyielded to fear for the stability of their currency, making last week’s rescue of Greece and Sunday night’s larger rescue package possible.
“I think Merkel was right in holding back, for domestic reasons toovercome the resistance and for external reasons to soften up theGreeks and others,” said Josef Joffe,editor of the German weekly Die Zeit. “Right now the morality play is,it’s her fault. I’m not her henchman, but on balance I think she didO.K., given what Germany’s underlying interests are.”
“If this works, we’ll look back two or three years from now and say, ‘Look what an ingenious woman she is,’ ” Mr. Joffe said.
In the short term, attention remains focused on Mrs. Merkel’s setbacks.Her Christian Democrats fell more than 10 percentage points in North Rhine-Westphalia’s state electionon Sunday, compared with the last vote there in 2005. While the partyclung to the largest share of the vote in the state, its 7.7percentage-point advantage over its left-wing rivals, the SocialDemocrats, shrank to 0.1 percentage point.
The Christian Democrats lost their ruling coalition in the state withthe pro-business Free Democrats, and as a result effective control of the upper house of Parliament, where each of Germany’s 16 states is represented.
“We suffered — and there’s no talking our way around it — a bitterdefeat,” Mrs. Merkel said at a party news conference on Monday, themorning after the election. She said that planned tax cuts would haveto be abandoned.
But she quickly shifted her attention to the legislation needed to passGermany’s share of the nearly $1 trillion emergency rescue fund.
She said her cabinet would meet Tuesday to approve the measure, sayingit was necessary to ensure the stability of the common euro currency,but also “to protect the money of our German citizens.”
Daniela Schwarzer, expert on European Union affairs at the German Institute for International and Security Affairsin Berlin, said that the larger rescue fund could be easier to sell tothe German public than the Greek bailout was, because of the publicdisapproval in Germany at what was seen as the irresponsible spendingof the Greeks.
“I expect the public perception of the next round is that there iscontagion to others and they are victims of the financial markets,” Ms.Schwarzer said. “This could be a new story to sell the big umbrellathat is being put into place.”
While Mrs. Merkel may win passage of the stability package, the loss ofcontrol of the upper house of Parliament would have long-reachingconsequences for her, according to Mr. Joffe of Die Zeit. As a result,all major legislative initiatives will require the approval ofopposition parties, a recipe for gridlock that will hamstring her athome and beyond Germany’s borders.
“The country destined to take the leadership mantle in Europe will notbe able to don it,” Mr. Joffe said. “She will not be able to lead, evenif she wanted to.”