2008-11-25 18:31:02Yvette

家後


(From YouTube.com)

上上禮拜簡直是江蕙週。【戲劇與劇場】課,學生討論  Everyman, 用了江蕙的〈家後〉 當作例子。全班除了我和那三位交換生,大家彷彿都同意。

到了星期五,【英美女詩人作品選】朗誦分享時刻,有個學生讀了 Emily Dickinson 的 "I cannot live with you" 又提到江蕙的〈家後〉,說她讀這首詩有一樣的流淚衝動。

後來又有第三個人提到〈家後〉。

接下來還有〈舞台人生〉.....

這麼多人會聽唱台語歌呀?嗯!很省腦力哦!(會不會只是因為垃圾模仿秀看太多的關係?)

話說呀.....更早的去年....

那一個號稱非常不感性的林小明不知道哪一根筋不對,說他一邊開車一邊聽〈家後〉,想到「YV 這二十年的辛苦」掉了一路的眼淚。我還問他那是什麼歌詞,知道之後幾乎笑斷大牙。我哪有那麼慘!?(很多不認識我的學生說我在路上看起來就是一副受虐婦女的典型,沒想到進教室之後看到的是一個搞笑的傢伙!)

可是我每次ㄧ轉身就又忘了查歌詞這件事。剛剛終於想到要 YouTube 一下。是這樣呀!我好像聽過了呀!

好!小朋友的聯想很好,雖然不同方向,不是"I cannot live WITHOUT you," 也算是懂詩的方法。

I cannot live with You (640)  
by Emily Dickinson
http://www.poets.org/viewmedia.php/prmMID/15802
 

I cannot live with You --

It would be Life --

And Life is over there --

Behind the Shelf

 

The Sexton keeps the Key to --

Putting up

Our Life -- His Porcelain --

Like a Cup --

 

Discarded of the Housewife --

Quaint -- or Broke --

A newer Sevres pleases --

Old Ones crack --

 

I could not die -- with You --

For One must wait

To shut the Other's Gaze down --

You -- could not --

 

And I -- Could I stand by

And see You -- freeze --

Without my Right of Frost --

Death's privilege?

 

Nor could I rise -- with You --

Because Your Face

Would put out Jesus' --

That New Grace

 

Glow plain -- and foreign

On my homesick Eye --

Except that You than He

Shone closer by --

 

They'd judge Us -- How --

For You -- served Heaven -- You know,

Or sought to --

I could not --

 

Because You saturated Sight --

And I had no more Eyes

For sordid excellence

As Paradise

 

And were You lost, I would be --

Though My Name

Rang loudest

On the Heavenly fame --

 

And were You -- saved --

And I -- condemned to be

Where You were not --

That self -- were Hell to Me --

 

So We must meet apart --

You there -- I -- here --

With just the Door ajar

That Oceans are -- and Prayer --

And that White Sustenance --

Despair --

http://www.poets.org/page.php/prmID/310

(A close reading of "I cannot live with you")

http://tw.youtube.com/watch?v=mRHiXKI3m3I

 (YouTube 有小朋友唸詩,還不錯!跟我學生差不多。呵呵呵!!!)